(Watch) Short-Term Rental Investing: Why the Market Beats the House Every Time

Most short-term rental deals don't go wrong because of the house. They go wrong because the investor bought in the wrong market or never ran real numbers.

On this episode of Real Estate Returns, Greg talks with Jen Levasseur, the Northwest Arkansas agent for Savvy STR Agent, a real estate team that works only with short-term rental investors. Jen has nine years of short-term rental experience in Northwest Arkansas. Here's what she wants every buyer to know.

Watch the full episode: YouTube · Apple Podcasts · Spotify

Start with your goal

Before Jen shows a single property, she asks what the investor wants. Most fall into one of three groups:

  • Tax benefits: they want the tax savings and don't need much cash flow.

  • Lifestyle: they want a place they can also use, and they're OK if it earns less.

  • Cash flow: they want the property to become real income, maybe a path to retirement.

Your goal shapes which property makes sense, and it's often different from what people first thought.

Know the market before the house

A regular agent can tell you why people move to an area. A short-term rental investor needs to know why people visit. In Northwest Arkansas, that includes things like mountain biking. It also means knowing whether three or four bedrooms do better in Bentonville, Rogers, or Fayetteville, and which amenities guests expect.

Local rules matter just as much. Jen shared that Bella Vista has capped short-term rental permits for homes where the owner doesn't live, and those permits don't transfer to a new owner. Fayetteville works differently, and Bentonville and Rogers had no restrictions when this was recorded. Always confirm the rules for the exact address before you make an offer.

Aim for the top 10%

Jen builds her projections on the top 10% of properties in a market, measured by revenue. That's on purpose. Market averages blend great rentals with poor ones: bad photos, tired design, hosts who aren't professional. If you plan to compete at the top, plan to invest like it.

That's why she asks "How much cash do you have to deploy?" instead of "What's your budget?" Your cash covers the down payment plus furniture, design, and amenities. Those extras usually come out of pocket, though seller credits can help on the front end.

Use more than one data tool

Jen mixes data tools such as AirDNA, BNBCalc, and Rabbu, since each one gathers its numbers differently. For a quick look, she recommends AirDNA's Rentalizer. Enter an address and it estimates occupancy (the share of nights booked), average daily rate, and yearly revenue.

To estimate a property, compare it to true comps: similar bedrooms, guest count, amenities, and location. Don't compare a two-bedroom to a four-bedroom. If a property is already a short-term rental, its past numbers help, but if you plan to upgrade it, they may undersell what it can do.

Pick amenities that pay

In Northwest Arkansas, Jen's must-haves are:

  • A hot tub

  • A bike wash station

  • Secure bike storage, like a shed, so bikes stay out of the living room

  • A coffee bar with more than just a coffee maker

From there, she looks at a game room and a strong outdoor space. Pools are rare in the market, so a heated or indoor pool can stand out. Barrel saunas, cold plunges, putting greens, pickleball courts, and an outdoor movie setup with a projector and popcorn machine all create a guest experience people pay for. Some cost less than you'd guess.

Build a full pro forma

A pro forma is a projection of what a property should earn and cost. Jen's version shows three scenarios based on local comps (good, better, best) and breaks out:

  • Gross revenue and average daily rate

  • Property taxes, insurance, utilities, and HOA dues

  • The loan and interest rate

  • Management fees and Airbnb or VRBO platform fees

  • Cash flow, cash-on-cash return, appreciation, and possible cost segregation benefits

She also recommends a lender who knows short-term rentals. Many investors use DSCR loans, where the lender checks whether the property's income covers the loan payment. A lender new to these loans can run into trouble at the appraisal.

It's not "mailbox money"

Long-term rental buyers often want something passive. Short-term rentals are a cash flow game that takes more money up front and more work. If you're after the tax benefits, Jen notes you'll need to be more hands-on, at least in the first year. Greg points out this ties to the material participation rules. The details depend on your situation, so talk to your CPA before you buy, not after.

Don't let the perfect deal cost you a good one

Jen's red flag for new investors: asking for property after property once the buy box is set. Analysis is good. Paralysis is not.

Her story proves it. About a year earlier, she found an off-market, fully furnished Bella Vista home for a mountain biker she'd been working with, before the permit cap. He passed. This year the same home became her listing, and he asked about it. By then, he couldn't get a permit.

Plan ahead for year-end

If you want cost segregation benefits this tax year, the property has to be bought and ready for guests before the year ends, and that takes time. Greg's advice: if you're hearing this late in the year, start planning for next year, and get moving before November.

Jen's top tip: know your numbers

Jen's main advice is simple: know your numbers before you put anything under contract. Find the balance between doing your homework and overthinking it.

As Greg likes to say, "The most underrated tax strategy for business owners is keeping good, clean books."

Thinking about a short-term rental? Cornerstone CPA works only with real estate investors, and we can help you plan the tax side before you buy.

Book your 15-minute discovery call

Previous
Previous

2027 IRS Tax Numbers Real Estate Investors Need

Next
Next

(Watch) How Commercial Lenders Size Up Real Estate Investors